Current Problems in Pediatric and Adolescent Health Care
Diagnostic Decision-Making and Strategies to Improve Diagnosis
Section snippets
Case Description
A 12-day-old infant presented with vomiting and bloody stool. At 6 days old, he began vomiting, which was followed by irritability and diarrhea. He was switched to a different feeding formula, which did not help relieve the symptoms. Six days later, he began having bloody stools with mucus and periods of inconsolable crying. An abdominal radiograph showed bowel gas paucity in the right lower quadrant suggestive of intussusception. The infant was then transferred to a tertiary care hospital for
Bounded Rationality
To achieve the optimal clinical outcome, clinicians are expected to make expert medical decisions leading to the right diagnosis and to recommend the most appropriate treatment. Along with experience and dedication, clinicians are expected to have expertise in making decisions based on a considerable amount of scientific data and rapidly increasing medical knowledge. The rationality of decision-makers, however, is limited by the availability of the information, the individuals' cognitive
Cognitive Solutions to Improve Diagnostic Decisions
The identification and implementation of strategies for decreasing or preventing such diagnostic errors has become a growing area of interest and research as well. Graber et al.25 conducted a comprehensive review of cognitive interventions to reduce diagnostic errors along with the supporting evidence for each. Adapted from the proposed framework, we summarize the recommended strategies into three approaches (Table 2). The first area focuses on increasing clinician clinical expertise. The
Expand Clinical Expertise
Strategies designed to increase the knowledge and experience of a clinician offer great opportunities to improve diagnostic accuracy for medical trainees and practicing clinicians alike. To truly work at increasing knowledge in a given area, clinicians must be aware of their own areas of knowledge deficit. Actual patient encounters in daily practices, simulated patient interactions, knowledge self-assessments, and continuing medical education (CME) activities offer several mechanisms for
Avoid Cognitive Processing Errors to Make Decisions Better
Efforts focused on avoiding cognitive processing errors in clinical encounters can present a challenge for trainees and practicing clinicians alike. We will divide our attention on two specific areas of focus related to errors in diagnostic reasoning: improving System 1 and System 2 processes.
Reduce Cognitive Burdens Via Cognitive Aids
Providing clinicians with external cognitive support offers another valuable way to decrease the likelihood of diagnostic errors. The use of specialist consultants or “second opinions” can support the clinician in an unsure diagnostic or therapeutic encounter.1, 38 The help can come in the form of additional expertise, ability to “play devil's advocate” or simply a “fresh set of eyes” to look at the clinical situation in a new angle. The application of “second reading” in radiology may be
Conclusions
Addressing cognitive processing errors is undeniably the most challenging task in reducing diagnostic errors. Given increasing attention in the cognitive contributions to diagnostic error, a large number of approaches and strategies have been discussed. They are predominantly based on theories and sciences in cognitive psychology, decision-making, and education. The proposed interventions, however, are primarily suggestions, and very few of them have been proven effective in the actual practice
References (48)
- et al.
Characteristics of skilled option generation in chess
Organ Behav Hum Decis Process
(1995) - et al.
Take the first: option generation and resulting choices
Organ Behav Hum Decis Process
(2003) - et al.
Error review: can this improve reporting performance?
Clin Radiol
(2001) Cognitive forcing strategies in clinical decision making
Ann Emerg Med
(2003)- et al.
Diagnostic error in internal medicine
Arch Intern Med
(2005) How Doctors Think: Clinical Judgment and the Practice of Medicine
(2006)How Doctors Think
(2007)- et al.
When Doctors Don't Listen: How to Avoid Misdiagnoses and Unnecessary Tests
(2013) Diagnostic error in medicine: the introduction
Adv in Health Sci Educ
(2009)- Simon HA. Rational decision making in business organizations. Nobel Memorial Lecture, December 8, 1978....