A study of energy-related injuries from hospital admissions among children and adults in South Africa
Introduction
Unintentional injuries remain one of the leading causes of death in the world, with burns accounting for a large portion of mortality; a disproportionately high percentage (over 95%) of these injuries occur in developing countries [1]. Africa in particular has a high prevalence of burn injuries due to poverty, overcrowding in housing communities, and poor living conditions [2]. The proportion of deaths among children due to burns is twice the level in low-income countries than it is in high-income countries, and infants in Africa specifically experience burns three times more than the world average [3]. While South Africa is viewed as one of the more developed African countries, rates of unintentional injuries such as burns and ingestions, remain high.
Many African countries utilize unsafe energy sources and lack infrastructure, putting them at even greater risk for injury [2]. Energy source usage refers to the pattern and combination of materials used in the home for cooking, heating, and/or lighting purposes. These usage patterns differ greatly between electrified and non-electrified homes. Examples of common energy sources include electricity, paraffin, firewood, candles, and gas [4]. South Africa in particular does not follow a typical energy ladder scheme in which higher income homes climb the ladder, but instead utilizes a mix of multiple energy sources [4]; the reason for this is multifactorial. Human factors such as knowledge of fuel source and appliances, physical environment setting such as dwelling size and escape points, and cultural practices all affect energy source usage [5]. Perhaps the biggest determinant of energy source usage is level of poverty; this affects the choice and quality of fuels, appliances, dwellings and frequently forces children to be left unattended [5].
Many South African low-income homes turn to paraffin (also known as kerosene) as their primary fuel source due to its lower cost and ease of accessibility for many families [6]. Paraffin, not to be confused with paraffin wax, is a hydrocarbon fuel created through the distillation of petroleum and is used most commonly for cooking and boiling water, however it is also used for lighting and heating purposes [7], [8]. As many as 92% of homes in South African informal settlements use paraffin on a daily basis [6]. Studies have found trends in injury patterns, commonly depending on age, gender, and race. Allorto and colleagues (2009) found that among pediatric burn patients aged 0–12 years, the median patient age is 3 years, but among burn patients over 12 years of age, the median patient age is 40 years [2]. Additionally, adults were found to sustain deeper burns to the skin than were children [2]. Children are at greater risk for experiencing a burn injury due to their reduced mobility, undeveloped risk perception, long sleeping hours, greater likelihood to sleep deeply, smaller surface area to body volume ratio, and physiological immaturity; these characteristics also put them at higher risk of experiencing adverse outcomes [8]. Generally speaking, population risk factors of childhood burn injury are low literacy and income levels, overall health status, and household crowding, with further risk associated when there is low socio-economic status (SES) of the family, low education level of the mother, and stress in the family [9]. More injuries likely occur in South Africa as a result of higher rates of poverty and unsafe use of paraffin [10].
While a number of studies have attempted to present the scope of energy-related burn and ingestion injuries in South Africa, none have been published with data from the number of hospitals and length as this study. Much of the literature has focused primarily on a small cohort or geographic region, however this study hopes to give a more inclusive view of the problem in South Africa. Current research also tends to focus on only one injury type—either burns or ingestions—but rarely focus on both of them [11], [12], [13].
Burns are any thermal injury that damages skin cells by hot liquid (scalds), hot solids (contact burns), flames (flame burns), electricity, friction, or radiation [14]. While burns have a higher incident rate overall, it is important to remember that ingestion injuries occur from paraffin and other fuels as well. Paraffin is considered a poison if ingested [12]. Paraffin enters the body through ingestion into the stomach or by inhalation of fumes and smoke [8]. The fatality rate is low, but can result due to respiratory failure from aspiration of paraffin into the lungs [7]. Because poisoning incidence among children is poorly documented, especially in developing countries [11], this study hopes to add to this documentation. It has also been noted that accurate and thorough injury surveillance and analysis is crucial in the planning of interventions, and that the lack of such data is a major problem in the battle against burn injuries [14]; this study seeks to strengthen this knowledge base. Overall, the objective of this study is to establish the scope of the problem of paraffin and other energy-related burn and ingestion injuries among children and adults in South African townships by determining demographic distribution of injuries, investigating when injuries occur, and analyzing characteristics of these injuries.
Section snippets
Settings and participants
Sixteen regional hospitals throughout South Africa were chosen for participation in this study if surrounding areas were known to have high incidence of energy-related injuries, which typically corresponded to areas of densely populated low-income housing. Participants were then selected from these institutions upon presentation of an energy-related injury from both hospital and emergency admissions. According to the 2011 South African Census, approximately 7 million people live in informal
Burn injuries
Between 2006 and 2012, 12,443 patients presented with an energy-related injury at 16 regional hospitals in South Africa. Fig. 2 shows the distribution of injuries by gender and age, as well as by injury type. Forty-seven percent were male. There were 5608 children with a mean age of 4.8 years (SD ± 3.8 years). The mean age of an adult was 31.3 years (SD ± 13.7 years). Black Africans comprised 77% of the population injured, followed by coloureds at 10% (“coloured” is an accepted ethnic category in
Burn injuries
Burn injuries were the predominant injury type in this study. Length of stay is an important indicator when looking at burn injuries as it can convey information on the gravity of the injury. Higher TBSA is associated with greater LOS in hospital as seen in Table 2. Length of stay peaks at 21–30% TBSA with a median stay of 13 days (95% CI: 0–62 days), and then decreases for >30% TBSA burns, possibly because patients are not surviving such severe burns. This finding is much shorter than what has
Conclusion
Burn and ingestion injuries are still a relatively common occurrence in low-income areas of South Africa. The results of this study show that very young children are sustaining a large percentage of these injuries (21% of injuries are to children aged 1–2 years) and that liquid burns are the most common injury type; nearly 70% of injuries to children 15 years or younger experience a liquid burn and they comprise 30% of the injuries in this study overall. Children burn a greater percentage of
Conflict of interest
The authors declare no conflicts of interest.
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank the Paraffin Safety Association of Southern Africa for the use of their dataset. The authors would also like to thank the research assistants who collected data over the years, all participating health institutions, and patients and their families for participating in this study. Finally the authors would like to thank Sumaiyah Docrat for her assistance in the initial phases of this manuscript.
References (25)
- et al.
The spectrum and outcome of burns at a regional hospital in South Africa
Burns
(2009) Epidemiology of burns throughout the world. Part I: distribution and risk factors
Burns
(2011)- et al.
Burns and injuries from non-electric-appliance fires in low- and middle-income countries. Part II. A strategy for intervention using the haddon matrix
Burns
(2008) - et al.
Incidence and patterns of childhood burn injuries in the Western Cape, South Africa
Burns
(2004) - et al.
A comparison of the epidemiology of paediatric burns in Scotland and South Africa
Burns
(2012) Epidemiology of burns throughout the world. Part I: distribution and risk factors
Burns
(2011)- et al.
The aetiology of adult burns in the Western Cape, South Africa
Burns
(2012) - et al.
The impact of a home visitation programme on household hazards associated with unintentional childhood injuries: a randomised controlled trial
Accid Anal Prev
(2009) World report on child injury prevention. Geneva
(2008)A survey of energy-related behaviour and perceptions in South Africa. Pretoria
(2012)
Paraffin-related injury in low-income South African communities: knowledge, practice and perceived risk
Bull World Health Organ
Paraffin ingestion – the problem
S Afr Med J
Cited by (22)
Assessing guidelines for burn referrals in a resource-constrained setting: Demographic and clinical factors associated with inter-facility transfer
2017, BurnsCitation Excerpt :Children with a burn visiting the TU during the period February 1st, 2015 and September 30th, 2015 were identified from the admission records at the TU. This eight-month period also covers the winter months associated with a higher incidence of burns [14,15]. In total, 907 children under the age of thirteen were identified with a burn.
The effect of seasonality on burn incidence, severity and outcome in Central Malawi
2017, BurnsCitation Excerpt :In addition, millions more suffer life-long disability and disfigurement from burns. These injuries are often attributable to cooking conditions and methods, poor access to safe energy source, crowded living conditions, and a lack of knowledge of potential risks [3]. Ultimately, burn is a disease of poverty.
Towards a multidimensional framework for measuring household energy access: Application to South Africa
2017, Energy for Sustainable DevelopmentA systematic review of burn injuries in low- and middle-income countries: Epidemiology in the WHO-defined African Region
2017, African Journal of Emergency MedicineCitation Excerpt :Chemical and electrical burns as well as intentional burns do occur and are among those admitted [41–44,52–66,69–70,75–98,100,102–106,107]. Many burn injuries occur during the cool/dry/windy months [52–66,68,75–86,100]. Epilepsy is a common contributing factor to burn injuries [47,50,62–66,68,74,100,107].