Review“Psychogenic” pain and the pain-prone patient☆
Abstract
The general principles formulated in this paper may be summarized as follows:
- 1.
1. What is experienced and reported as pain is a psychological phenomenon. Pain does not come into being without the operation of the psychic mechanisms which give rise to its indentifiable qualities and which permit its perception. In neurophysiological terms this also means there is no pain without the participation of higher nervous centers.
- 2.
2. Developmentally, however, pain evolves from patterns of impulses arising from peripheral receptors which are part of the basic biologic nocioceptive system for the protection of the organism from injury. The psychic experience, pain, develops phylogenetically and ontogenetically from what was originally only a reflex organization. This may be compared to the necessity for functioning eyes and ears to receive light and sound waves before the complex psychic experiences of seeing and hearing can evolve.
- 3.
3. Once the psychic organization necessary for pain has evolved, the experience, pain, no longer requires peripheral stimulation to be provoked, just as visual and auditory sensations (hallucinations) may occur without sense organ input. When such are projected outside the mind (in contrast to a painful thought or a painful frame of mind) they are felt as being in some part of the body and are to the patient indistinguishable from pain arising in the periphery.
- 4.
4. Since the experience, pain, and the sensory experiences from which it evolves are part of the biologic equipment whereby the individual learns about the environment and about his body, and since this has a special function as a warning or indicator of damage to body parts, pain plays an important role in the total psychologic development of the individual. Indeed, pain, along with other affects, comes to occupy a key position in the regulation of the total psychic economy. We discover that in the course of the child's development, pain and relief of pain enter into the formation of interpersonal (object) relations and into the concepts of good and bad, reward and punishment, success and failure. Pain becomes par excellence a means of assuaging guilt and thereby influences object relationships.
- 5.
5. From the clinical viewpoint we discover that disordered neural patterns originating in the periphery confer certain qualities on the pain experience that permit the physician to recognize their presence and hence make a presumptive diagnosis of an organic lesion.
- 6.
6. Clinical psychological studies of all varieties of patients with pain reveal that some individuals are more prone than others to use pain as a psychic regulator, whether the pain includes a peripheral source of stimulation or not. These pain-prone individuals usually show some or all of the following features:
- 6.1.
(1) A prominance of conscious and unconscious guilt, with pain serving as a relatively satisfactory means of atonement.
- 6.2.
(2) A background that tends to predispose to the use of pain for such purposes.
- 6.3.
(3) A history of suffering and defeat and intolerance of success (masochistic character structure). A propensity to solicit pain, as evidenced by the large number of painful injuries, operations and treatments.
- 6.4.
(4) A strong aggressive drive which is not fulfilled, pain being experienced instead.
- 6.5.
(5) Development of pain as a replacement for a loss at times when a relationship is threatened or lost.
- 6.6.
(6) A tendency toward a sado-masochistic type of sexual development, with some episodes of pain occurring in settings of conflict over sexual impulses.
- 6.7.
(7) A location of pain determined by unconscious identification with a love object, the pain being either one suffered by the patient himself when in some conflict with the object or a pain suffered by the object in fact or in the patient's fantasy.
- 6.8.
(8) Psychiatric diagnoses include conversion hysteria, depression, hypochondriasis and paranoid schizophrenia, or mixtures of these. Some patients with pain do not fit into any distinct nosologie category.
- 6.1.
References (22)
- H.K. Beecher
Limiting factors in experimental pain
J. Chronic Dis.
(1956) - T. Szasz
Pain and Pleasure
(1957) - P. Solomon et al.
Sensory deprivation. A review
Am. J. Psychiat.
(1957) - H. Osmond
A review of the clinical effects of psychotomimetic agents
Ann. New York Acad. Sc.
(1957) - W. Penfield et al.
Epilepsy and the Functional Anatomy of the Human Brain
(1954) - W. Gooddy
On the nature of pain
Brain
(1957) - H. Rosen
The hypnotic and hypnotherapeutic control of severe pain
Am. J. Psychiat.
(1951) - J. Breuer et al.
Studies on Hysteria (1895)
- P. Schilder
The Image and Appearance of the Human Body
(1935) - G.L. Engel
Primary atypical facial neuralgia. An hysterical conversion symptom
Psychosom. Med.
(1951)
Psychiatric aspects of pain
Psychosom. Med.
Cited by (563)
Pain Catastrophizing: Controversies, Misconceptions and Future Directions
2024, Journal of PainRecent reports have pointed to problems with the term “pain catastrophizing.” Critiques of the term pain catastrophizing have come from several sources including individuals with chronic pain, advocates for individuals with chronic pain, and pain scholars. Reports indicate that the term has been used to dismiss the medical basis of pain complaints, to question the authenticity of pain complaints, and to blame individuals with pain for their pain condition. In this paper, we advance the position that the problems prompting calls to rename the construct of pain catastrophizing have little to do with the term, and as such, changing the term will do little to solve these problems. We argue that continued calls for changing or deleting the term pain catastrophizing will only divert attention away from some fundamental flaws in how individuals with pain conditions are assessed and treated. Some of these fundamental flaws have their roots in the inadequate training of health and allied health professionals in evidence-based models of pain, in the use of psychological assessment and intervention tools for the clinical management of pain, and in gender equity and antiracism. Critiques that pain scholars have leveled against the defining, operational, and conceptual bases of pain catastrophizing are also addressed. Arguments for reconceptualizing pain catastrophizing as a worry-related construct are discussed. Recommendations are made for remediation of the problems that have contributed to calls to rename the term pain catastrophizing.
The issues prompting calls to rename the construct of pain catastrophizing have their roots in fundamental flaws in how individuals with pain are assessed and treated. Efforts to address these problems will require more than a simple change in terminology.
Adolescent Alcohol Exposure Produces Sex-Specific Long-term Hyperalgesia via Changes in Central Amygdala Circuit Function
2024, Biological PsychiatryExposure to alcohol during adolescence produces many effects that last well into adulthood. Acute alcohol use is analgesic, and people living with pain report drinking alcohol to reduce pain, but chronic alcohol use produces increases in pain sensitivity.
We tested the acute and lasting effects of chronic adolescent intermittent ethanol (AIE) exposure on pain-related behavioral and brain changes in male and female rats. We also tested the long-term effects of AIE on synaptic transmission in midbrain (ventrolateral periaqueductal gray [vlPAG])-projecting central amygdala (CeA) neurons using whole-cell electrophysiology. Finally, we used circuit-based approaches (DREADDs [designer receptors exclusively activated by designer drugs]) to test the role of vlPAG-projecting CeA neurons in mediating AIE effects on pain-related outcomes.
AIE produced long-lasting hyperalgesia in male, but not female, rats. Similarly, AIE led to a reduction in synaptic strength of medial CeA cells that project to the vlPAG in male, but not female, rats. Challenge with an acute painful stimulus (i.e., formalin) in adulthood produced expected increases in pain reactivity, and this effect was exaggerated in male rats with a history of AIE. Finally, CeA-vlPAG circuit activation rescued AIE-induced hypersensitivity in male rats.
Our findings are the first, to our knowledge, to show long-lasting sex-dependent effects of adolescent alcohol exposure on pain-related behaviors and brain circuits in adult animals. This work has implications for understanding the long-term effects of underage alcohol drinking on pain-related behaviors in humans.
At the intersection of anger, chronic pain, and the brain: A mini-review
2022, Neuroscience and Biobehavioral ReviewsChronic pain remains one of the most persistent healthcare challenges in the world. To advance pain treatment, experts have recently introduced research-driven subtypes of chronic pain based on proposed underlying mechanisms. Nociplastic pain (e.g., nonspecific chronic low back or fibromyalgia) is one such subtype which may involve a greater etiologic role for brain plasticity, painful emotions induced by life stress and trauma, and unhealthy emotion regulation. In particular, correlational and behavioral data link anger and the ways anger is regulated with the presence and severity of nociplastic pain. Functional neuroimaging studies also suggest nociplastic pain and healthy anger regulation demonstrate inverse patterns of activity in the medial prefrontal cortex and amygdala; thus, improving anger regulation could normalize activity in these regions. In this Mini-Review, we summarize these findings and propose a unified, biobehavioral model called the Anger, Brain, and Nociplastic Pain (AB-NP) Model, which can be tested in future research and may advance pain care by informing new treatments that address anger, anger regulation, and brain plasticity for nociplastic pain.
Reward processing as a common diathesis for chronic pain and depression
2021, Neuroscience and Biobehavioral ReviewsPain disorders and psychiatric illness are strongly comorbid, particularly in the context of Major Depressive Disorder (MDD). While these disorders account for a significant amount of global disability, the mechanisms of their overlap remain unclear. Understanding these mechanisms is of vital importance to developing prevention strategies and interventions that target both disorders. Of note, brain reward processing may be relevant to explaining how the comorbidity arises, given pain disorders and MDD can result in maladaptive reward responsivity that limits reward learning, appetitive approach behaviours and consummatory response. In this review, we discuss this research and explore the possibility of reward processing deficits as a common diathesis to explain the manifestation of pain disorders and MDD. Specifically, we hypothesize that contextual physical or psychological events (e.g. surgery, divorce) in the presence of a reward impairment diathesis worsens symptoms and results in a negative feedback loop that increases the chronicity and probability of developing the other disorder. We also highlight the implications for treatment and provide a framework for future research.
Psychological status before and after surgery in patients with trigeminal neuralgia
2021, Clinical Neurology and NeurosurgeryTo analyze the psychological status in patients with trigeminal neuralgia before surgery and in the early postoperative period after microvascular decompression of the trigeminal nerve.
Psychological features of personality were studied in 56 patients aged from 28 to 80 years with trigeminal neuralgia. To study the psychological status, such scales as Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale, Pain Catastrophizing Scale and Patient's Subjective Assessment of Treatment Effectiveness Scale (PSATES) were used with special attention paid to presence of suicidal thoughts.
The signs of anxiety were clinically significant in 7%, absent - in 66 % of the patients. There were no signs of depression in 63 % of cases, while 7% of the patients suffered from clinically significant depression. Pain catastrophizing was observed in 76.8 % of patients. None of the patients rated the intervention as "excellent" on PSATES despite the complete pain relief in the majority of patients (78.6 %), and only 16.1 % of the patients rated it as "good". The aggravation factor had a significant influence on this evaluation (p = 0.01).
General psychological status assessment can be used to objectify the indicators of the questionnaires and pain scales, as well as to determine the treatment tactics in this group, especially when it is necessary to clarify indications for an intervention and to decide on its proper time. Regardless of the outcome, the patients need time and psychological help for social adaptation due to changes in their social status.
Trauma-related guilt and pain among veterans with PTSD
2020, Psychiatry ResearchDespite the well-known co-occurrence of posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and chronic pain, large gaps remain in understanding how these two conditions influence each other. The aim of the present study was to examine the association between trauma-related guilt and pain among veterans with PTSD. Participants were 140 veterans enrolling in treatment for PTSD and alcohol use disorder. Trauma-related guilt was assessed by the trauma-related guilt inventory, including the global guilt, distress, and guilt cognitions scales. Measures of pain included pain severity, pain disability, and fear of pain. Several significant bivariate associations were observed between trauma-related guilt scales and pain outcomes; however, in linear regression models, only the association between thoughts of trauma-related guilt and fear of pain remained statistically significant after controlling for confounding factors. Further, thoughts of trauma-related guilt, specifically thoughts of wrongdoing, partially mediated the association between PTSD severity and fear of pain. Our findings suggest that trauma-related guilt may play a role in the relationship between PTSD and chronic pain. Future research is encouraged to examine thoughts of trauma-related guilt as a potential therapeutic target in the treatment of persons with comorbid PTSD and chronic pain.
- ☆
Supported in part by a grant from the Foundations Fund for Research in Psychiatry.
- 1
Departments of Psychiatry and Medicine, University of Rochester School of Medicine and Dentistry, Rochester, New York.